Login Register

Did Fred West murder Mary Bastholm - the detective's story part 1

By The Citizen  |  Posted: December 28, 2011

  • Mary Bastholm

Comments (0) THE disappearance in Gloucester of teenager Mary Bastholm in 1968 remains unsolved to this day.Here, retired Detective Chief Superintendent John Bennett, who led the investigation into the Cromwell Street murders, asks whether Fred West was to blame:

I WAS off duty when I received a request from police headquarters control room to phone Winson Green Prison Deputy Governor Polkinghorn.

It was just after 1.30pm on New Year's Day 1995 and Frederick West was on remand there to await trial, with his wife Rosemary, for the murders of 12 young women – including his first wife and her daughter, and a daughter from his bigamous marriage to Rose.

Rose was jointly charged with 10 of those murders.

I instinctively knew what was coming.

I had even cynically prepared a plan of action in the event of Frederick West's suicide or death and kept it in my briefcase.

Now my worst fears were realised.

I had visited that maximum security prison wing in October purely for the purpose of warning those responsible for his detention that it had come to our investigation's notice, from more than one source, that West's attitude had changed since he had left Gloucester police station and that he might be contemplating suicide.

On leaving the prison that day both Deputy Detective Chief Inspector Terry Moore and I were far from comfortable with what we had seen and heard.

It seemed, despite having expressed our reasoned concerns, our fears might be unheeded.

We were told of the previous high-profile prisoners that had been cared for on that wing without a problem and that Frederick West in comparison was a breeze.

We knew otherwise and had made clear how he was able to manipulate others and quickly and cunningly take advantage of situations.

We knew that he was not the simpleton he portrayed but an evil, conniving psychopath with no conscience whatsoever.

I went to my bedroom to ensure privacy and escape the noise of mine and my sister's family who were visiting for dinner and made the requested call to the deputy governor.

My worst fears were realised – West had somehow asphyxiated himself in his cell. West Midlands Police had been informed.

I did not ask for any more details or make comment, just said thank you for the call and ended it.

The how and when West met his death would be dealt with by the Birmingham Coroner in time, now I had to ensure those who needed to know were informed by the investigating team before the media got hold of it.

I knew how difficult it would be to win that race.

My plan placed first and foremost notification to the families of the victims, including the West family.

The family of Mary Bastholm was included as, while West had denied involvement in her disappearance, it was so similar to that of other known victims it had been strongly put to me on a number of occasions.

I had promised her family personally, like I had all the others, that I would keep them aware of any developments I could.

As I collected myself, I was momentarily overcome by feelings of frustration and anger.

West had played a winning and cheating card and taken with him the truth of how the victims had met their deaths as well if there were any further victims.

And also whether he was involved in Mary's disappearance, which took place before he had met Rose. That would now likely never be known.

As I began to make the calls to staff up in the incident room to put the plan into action, many thoughts and memories flashed through my mind.

Apart from what this meant to the investigation and now Rose West's lone trial, I knew the disappointment the investigating team would feel and that very much would relate to the unanswered questions of Mary Bastholm's disappearance.


Stroud Police Station and magistrates court, situated on the junction of Gloucester Street and Slad Road, looked cold and uninviting just after 8.30am that Sunday morning.

It was January 14, 1968, and I was a detective constable in the force.

I stamped my feet on the doormat, removing the ice and snow from my shoes at the entrance before opening the door to be greeted by the warmth of the front office.

PC Ted Jones, the general office duty clerk, greeted me as I went to the tier of filing baskets.

I first scooped up the pile of messages from the basket designated "CID" before casting my eyes over other messages that related more to my uniform colleagues.

As I brought myself up to date, before going upstairs to the CID General Office, Ted Jones commented: "I see they've called in the Yard for the girl missing from Gloucester then."

It had been bitterly cold over Christmas and especially the previous week when there had been more than one fall of snow.

Gloucester, Cheltenham and the Cotswolds were experiencing the same cold snap – the county's pavements were an obstacle to any able-bodied pedestrian while conditions, even on main roads, were exciting to say the least for the few drivers who dared to venture out.

I was then 22 years old and had less than three years service as a sworn police officer.

I had been a police cadet since I was 17 years old.

As a probationer PC, like all others, I been moved regularly.

Now I was a detective constable, having recently been appointed before having attended an initial detective training course at the Metropolitan Police Detective Training School – a course that had only ended some two weeks previously.

That morning, having fully briefed myself and listed what had to be done, I looked out over Merrywalks considering myself to be fortunate.

I enjoyed every aspect of my work as a police officer and especially "catching thieves".

Now investigating crime was my main responsibility, though when the need for underwater searches arose I retained another role.

I was a proud member of the Gloucestershire Constabulary Underwater Recovery Section, formed two years earlier.

Sitting at my desk while doing my "to do list", I was joined by my more experienced opposite number and neighbour – Detective Constable Brian Watkins.

We discussed the disappearance of Mary Jane Bastholm, the girl missing from Gloucester, and the investigation that was being carried out there.

It had been run initially by Gloucestershire's head of CID, Detective Chief Superintendent Dick Tilley, but now Scotland Yard had been called in.

The local newspapers were full of it and there had been a number of circulations by telex (the automated system used in those days by police and organisations to communicate typed text but not photographs).

These, and the TV reports and internal circulations, clearly indicated that it was not just because of the weather that there was highest concern for her wellbeing. It was also the circumstances of her disappearance – it was completely out of character.

The constabulary's internal paper circulation Daily Informations added weight to the telex circulations and included a photograph, as did the wider circulated South West Crime Information.

Later, if she was not found, she would appear in the country-wide circulated Police Gazette. Sadly, this was to become necessary.

The photograph that accompanied the circulation showed Mary apparently as a happy and smiling young bridesmaid.

The detail included: "She is 16 years of age, born on March 14, 1952, 5' 3" tall, very slim build with blonde coloured hair straight and of shoulder length, parted in the centre.

"She was wearing a navy blue knee-length coat with vertical pin stripes, buttons down the front, a navy jumper, navy blue cardigan, darker in colour, with buttons to the neck, a lime green mini skirt and navy blue shoes and handbag.

"She was carrying a Monopoly set in a white carrier bag and was last seen at 8.15pm on Saturday, January 6, 1968, at a bus stop in Bristol Road, Gloucester."

"Marchand Of the Yard" - Detective Chief Superintendent William Marchand of the Metropolitan Police Scotland Yard Murder Squad – was now heading the investigation.

NOTES:MARY Bastholm disappeared at the age of 15 and was last seen at a Gloucester bus stop in January 1968.She worked at the Pop In cafe, which was frequented by Fred West. His son Stephen said his father had confessed to murdering her before he killed himself. West, 53, hanged himself in Winson Green Prison on New Year’s Day 1995 as he awaited trial for 12 murders. Most victims were found at his home at 25 Cromwell Street but Mary’s body was never found.

Read more from Gloucester Citizen

Do you have something to say? Leave your comment here...

max 4000 characters
  • marshallfilm  |  January 21 2012, 10:08PM

    Hi, I'm a film production student from Uni of Glos. As our final piece, a class mate and I are looking into doing a documentary on Mary Bastholm's dissappearance. I have noticed that John Bennett, the dective has commented on a few posts, I don't know much of another way to reach out to you, but if you would be interested in contributing towards a student documentary, or atleast would give us a chance to share our vision for the documentary, can you please email me at marshallfilm@live.co.uk Thank You, Elizabeth

  • Andrew_Powell  |  January 13 2012, 1:15PM

    As of today 326 people have signed the petition. That's a lot of people the police should be listening to.

    |   2
  • Chris2308  |  January 05 2012, 12:22PM

    Phil, thanks for that. I also don't have a great deal of faith in online petitions but most of them are asking for the world to change overnight or demanding money from a pot that doesn't exist. This petition is very different in that it is DEMANDING that the police do what they should have done in 1994, i.e their job. Someone in the force made the clear and conscious decision not to search for any more of Fred West's victims and with a potential of more than 300 possible sites, who could blame them. However, whether or not Mary is buried at the cafe is in one way immaterial. The indicators are so strong that had the police conducted a hierarchical analysis ( as they are paid to do ) of potential burial sites, the cafe would have been smack bang on top of the list. No "new evidence" is necessary to reach the conclusion that I and many others have. What is apparent and no moreso than in the recent Stephen Lawrence case, is that the Police regard their main job as obtaining convictions. Once they've done that, no need to do anything else and that, in this circumstance, is just plain wrong. If they don't find Mary at the cafe and there's no guarantee that they will, at least they have TRIED to find her. It will also in some small way provide closure to the family because they will be able to walk down Southgate Street again without a cloud descending on them.

    |   2
  • HuckiePhil  |  January 05 2012, 10:35AM

    Chris I don't have a huge amount of faith in online petitions, but I've signed and emailled my contact book with the link. This added to keep the thread uppermost - as Mary and her family and friends should be in our thoughts, even if this all comes to nought.

  • Alchemies  |  January 05 2012, 9:52AM

    'by messyhareThursday, January 05 2012, 9:28AM "One would have thought, someone as on the ball as Alch... Chris would have known that?" Every time you post this nonsense I will report you. Understood?

  • BlokeA1  |  January 05 2012, 9:13AM

    Chris - Richard Graham is Gloucester's MP.

    |   1
  • Chris2308  |  January 05 2012, 2:52AM

    It has just occurred to me that today , 5th January, is the 44th anniversary of the last time Mary was seen alive. So very sad.

  • Chris2308  |  January 05 2012, 12:05AM

    One interesting signatory on the petition, thus. Name: Chris Tw=t Roberts on Jan 4, 2012 Comments: Ya a s**t shirring t0sser So it looks like we have at least one person who would rather that Mary not be found. Care to come out of hiding so we can discuss it ? No , I thought not.

  • omorley  |  January 04 2012, 9:40PM

    Fascinating thread. I have signed the petition, and I hope it is acted upon by the Police. You can half understand at the time of the Wests' investigation the Police wanting to put closure on the case for a number of reasons, but it does seem strange that the evidence wasn't acted upon at the time. After all, it was Fred's word that led to the field searches near Much Marcle and the discovery of Charmaine West's body in the West's previous property (which if I recall helped to convict Rose, so hopefully she wouldn't have been walking the streets, even if she took the defence line as Chris mentioned), so it does seem a bit odd that this wasn't part of the investigation. Best of luck with the petition.

  • Chris2308  |  January 04 2012, 5:51PM

    BlokleA, thanks again for your support but who is Richard Graham and what can he add?