Login Register

What the Butler saw: Peter Butler's column

By The Citizen  |  Posted: December 30, 2013

Comments (24)

What is the point of rules if they are ignored?

NIGEL Davies stood up and said what everyone has been thinking in the wake of the victory over London Irish on Sunday.

As per Aviva Premiership rules, Leicester shouldn’t have been speaking to Freddie Burns and Freddie Burns shouldn’t have been speaking to Leicester before January.

Instead, it seems a deal is already done and Gloucester are resigned to losing their fly-half to the Tigers for next season.

What’s the point of having rules if they are going to be roundly ignored when it comes to the crunch?

This is a Premiership-wide issue, brought to the fore by Leicester’s pursuit of Burns as they lose Toby Flood to France next season.

Up to this point it has been brushed under the carpet, but now Davies has been brave enough to come out and say something the issue must warrant some investigation.

There may be some sour grapes on Gloucester’s part because they look likely to lose a star talent, but setting that aside there is clearly an issue that needs to be addressed and certainly a loophole that needs tightening if agents are allowed to speak on a player’s behalf to avoid breaching the regulations. This sort of ‘you tell him we said this’ approach is more reminiscent of a canned laughter sitcom than a way to conduct recruitment in professional sport.

As for Burns, this season is in danger of doing serious damage to his reputation, both on and off the field.

His form has plummeted in a manner which has clearly damaged Gloucester’s prospects – and he admits this is down to having his head turned by off-the-field matters.

The indication is he wants to leave for the Tigers to better his chances of playing international rugby.

To that, I would say this: He has achieved international recognition playing in the cherry and white of Gloucester.

Once you have been recognised as international quality, it’s up to you to go out and live up to it on the field.

The sort of inconsistency Burns has shown, however you want to explain it, stains his international reputation.

Owen Farrell will always get the nod at international level because of his kicking consistency. Burns has shown it in fits and starts, but never regularly enough to be trusted in the England number 10 shirt.

We needed those wins to ease the pressure

TWO ugly wins over the last two weeks will have given morale around Gloucester a huge boost, as well as the position in the Premiership table.

To back up the hard-fought Worcester victory with success at London Irish was a huge step for Nigel Davies’ men.

It provides clear evidence the players are ready to pull together to drag Gloucester out of the situation they are in.

Once again it was a performance that lacked any kind of fluidity or continuity. Glouc-were outscored three tries to one and the one score they did manage came from cheeky opportunism.

But Billy Twelvetrees and latterly Freddie Burns kicked the kicks and in the end it was just enough to see the Cherry and Whites homes.

London Irish were given a lesson in how important it is to land those conversions and penalties, a lesson Gloucester have been on the receiving end of too many times this season.

It was the much-maligned forwards who won most of those penalties.

They deserved the plaudits as a unit for the last two games. Clearly they have pulled together in the face of adversity and dragged their team over the line.

Whether these wins can be building blocks for some true form remains to be seen, but for the time being trouble is a bit further away.

Saracens will be tough

WHETHER Gloucester will be able to play poorly and win against Saracens this weekend is another case entirely.

You would imagine the Cherry and Whites will have to take their game up several notches to get within range of the Premiership leaders, who have only lost once in the league all season.

But if you think back to the corresponding fixture at Saracens at the start of the season, Gloucester stayed in the game until into the second half despite going down to 14 men so early with Nick Wood’s sending off. It’s time to start showing visiting teams what coming to Kingsholm is all about.

Four teams have beaten Gloucester at home in the league this season, and that simply isn’t good enough.

The wins over Worcester and London Irish have dragged Gloucester clear of trouble, but they can’t be satisfied with just that. It’s time to make a statement for the second half of the season and there is no better way of doing that than getting on over on the league leaders.

Do you have something to say? Leave your comment here...

max 4000 characters


  • Rory-GIaws  |  January 01 2014, 4:02PM

    With all the risible guff we are getting from the Gloucester Rugby hating rent-a-quote troll of many names and identities (currently pushing his Walker100b ID) he can't get away from the fact that is wholly attributable to Rupҽrt Hardҽn, which is that he is the number 1 tight head at Gloucester. The number of times he has been selected to start proves it. But since the rent-a-quote troll, Walker100b, is not a Gloucester Rugby supporter, he wouldn't know any of that.

    Rate   9
  • SamGlaws33  |  January 01 2014, 3:57PM

    Well done to Rupҽrt Hardҽn for proving time and time again why he is Nigel Davies' first choice tight head. The sheep pleasuring multi-ID rent-a-quote troll Walker100b/gloslover-not/dopey-lerone can't get over the fact that the man who selects the team knows better than him and that is why he always selects Harden for the tough/crucial games.

    Rate   9
  • mattw76  |  January 01 2014, 3:53PM

    The dopey Gloucester Rugby hating rent-a-quote troll Walker100b aka shedheadnot/gloslover-not/dumbanddumber20/dopey-lerone/bikeshed etc. with all his other user names, can claim all he likes that he knows better than the coaching staff about who is the first choice tight head at Gloucester.... he doesn't! Thankfully, ND is the one who selects the team and time after time, he selects Rupҽrt Hardҽn as his starting tight head prop.

    Rate   9
  • Sandy622  |  January 01 2014, 3:50PM

    Harden is the number 1 tight head at Gloucester Rugby. If the sad lonely old mad and multi-ID rent-a-quote troll Walker100b aka gloslover-not/dumbanddumber20/dopey-lerone, ever gets to a Gloucester Rugby game he could see that for himself but he never goes to any games because the matron at his home never lets him out, so he spends all his lonely hours on the net trolling. He doesn't even support Gloucester anyway.

    Rate   9
  • SamGlaws33  |  January 01 2014, 3:47PM

    I love the way, week after week, that Rupҽrt Hardҽn plants a great big dollop of egg on the face of the multi-ID rent-a-quote troll Walker100b/gloslover-not/dumbanddumber20/dopey-lerone/bikeshed etc. (whichever one he thinks he is today). The troll wouldn't know a decent tight-head if he was slapped around the head by one, though he would enjoy the experience immensely.

    Rate   9
  • Rory-GIaws  |  January 01 2014, 3:45PM

    A troll is a troll and the rent-a-quote troll Walker100b, who also posts his dull nonsense under the identities of gloslover-not/dumbanddumber20/dopey-lerone, is a clueless Gloucester Rugby and Rupҽrt Hardҽn hating troll who has no idea where Kingsholm is because he doesn't even support Gloucester Rugby, He has no idea about rugby union either as he loves watching wendyball.

    Rate   9
  • Sandy622  |  January 01 2014, 3:42PM

    Laughing at the clueless Gloucester Rugby and Rupҽrt Hardҽn hating rent-a-quote troll Walker100b aka gloslover-not/dopey-lerone/bikeshed/dumbanddumber20 pretending that he knows anything about rugby or that he is remotely interested in Gloucester Rugby. He is getting so upset because his "partner" has sprung a leak and Halfords isn't open so that he can get a puncture repair kit. Ha! Ha! Ha! Ha! Ha!

    Rate   9
  • SamGlaws33  |  January 01 2014, 3:40PM

    Ha! Ha! Ha! Laugh at the useless Gloucester Rugby and Rupҽrt Hardҽn hating rent-a-quote troll Walker100b aka shedheadNEVER aka gloslover-not or DumbAndDumber20 or dopey_lerone if he prefers. He is soooo upset that he has been found out with his latest identity. He knows absolutely nothing about rugby union, sat in his sad home for sad lonely old men.

    Rate   9
  • Rory-GIaws  |  January 01 2014, 3:39PM

    And there you have it from the self confessed troll, Walker100b. He enjoys trolling much more than fishing. What a sad buffoon he must be. Harden = Gloucester Rugby's first choice tight head. No doubt about it!

    Rate   9
  • mattw76  |  January 01 2014, 3:36PM

    Laugh at the brain-dead troll Walker100b aka shedheadNOT aka gloslover-NOT pretending to be a Gloucester Rugby supporter. The fact is, he is a clueless idiot who knows absolutely nothing about Gloucester Rugby or rugby union. In fact, he knows so little about anything that it comes as no surprise that he is a veritable puppet on a string but is far too simple to know it. Ha! Ha! |Ha!.

    Rate   9